Was the murderer – who brutally killed 84 people, injuring hundreds more in Nice, France, a practicing Muslim?
Or, was he, as reports indicate, a depressed, lonely man with mental health problems, a propensity for using drugs and alcohol, and a criminal history – the very antithesis of a practicing Muslim?
The answers to these questions don’t seem to matter to everyone. Several politicians, TV personalities and pundits, set out to form public sentiment surrounding the attack within the very first hours after it occurred.
Before any details were available, the branding of this attack as a radical “Islamic” terror attack had already begun.
I heard the terms “Islamic terrorism” and “radical Islamic terrorism” repeated over and over again.
I heard people insist that these attacks won’t stop until we “call it what it really is” and dutifully attach the word “Islam” to every single terror instigating crime we witness.
High profile people such as Donald Trump, Newt Gingrich– and a slew of far right-wing politicians and networks framed this attack as a sign of a clash of civilizations – clear as day – a war between Islam and the west. Gingrich went so far as to say, “Western civilization is in a war. We should frankly test every person here who is of Muslim background and if they believe in sharia, they should be deported. Sharia is incompatible with Western civilization.”
I believe in Shariah, which is the same thing as believing in Islam.
Do they know that being kind to your family is part of the Shariah, along with prayer, charity, being honest, oh – and don’t forget – obeying the laws of the land in which we live?
Do they care?
For American Muslims, being good citizens is literally mandated by the Shariah. I don’t know where Mr. Gingrich would like to send me. My great grandparents were born here in the USA. There are American Muslims whose ancestry dates way further back in America than mine – some can trace back centuries, some all the way to the Mayflower, and some American Muslims trace their heritage straight back to the Native Americans.
If the Native Americans who are now Muslims could be deported back in time… that would be interesting, because there’d be no sign of Gingrich’s ancestors or Trump’s on American soil.
The Results are Polarizing
Imagine, all this vitriol, all this certainty, all this “educating” went on before any information whatsoever, aside from the rising death toll, had been uncovered. Clearly, this notion of testing and deporting Muslims isn’t tenable – but what all these hateful statements did, is perpetuate the notion that Muslims are foreign – period. This divisive view of our world – us vs. them; paints a black and white, and very frightening picture for vulnerable Americans. The more people see a polarized world, the more they feel obliged and compelled to take a side.
They are training us to instinctively see all horrific incidents as being tied to Islam. Whether they really are or not is beside the point. This helps to advance the positions and agendas of powerful politicians and corporations – but tears our society apart, and that does matter.
SMH and Complain?
We can get upset and shake our fingers at this irresponsible use of fame and ability to reach millions of people’s brains. We can struggle against every troll on the Internet and argue about just how anti-Islam these crimes really are. Yes, the facts prove the islamophobes and everyone else trying to force a war down our throats, utterly wrong – but the truth alone cannot alter the toxic atmosphere being systematically created.
The Heat is On
One of the effects of being constantly suspect is that the one under suspicion begins to feel guilty – even if he or she is totally innocent. Dalia Mogahed explained how she felt after 9/11 saying:
“Not only had my country been attacked, but in a flash, somebody else’s actions had turned me from a citizen to a suspect… for the first time in my life, [I was] afraid for anyone to know I was a Muslim.”
This is reinforced by a few, very loud voices claiming that we are all suspect. After the Nice attacks, Kelvin Mackenzie, a columnist from the UK’s Sun newspaper wrote a controversial column questioning why a “young woman wearing a hijab” had been allowed to report on the attack in Nice. He was appalled that the reporter, Fatima Manji was visibly Muslim. He asked. “Was it appropriate for her to be on camera when there had been yet another shocking slaughter by a Muslim?”
Avoiding the Herd Mentality
More than 1/3 of the dead, killed by the attacker in Nice, were Muslims. If it’s offensive for a Muslim to report the attack on television, is it also offensive for us to mourn our dead?
We have to reject this idea and think critically: Is it wrong for white Christians to report news about attacks committed by white Christians? To suggest so is clearly, easily and immediately recognized as preposterous.
We cannot allow others to determine how we feel about ourselves. We have to be the leaders of our own thoughts – to employ reasoning, and thoughtfully listen and consider the facts and points of view before settling on our position.
God has differentiated between those who are unthinking and sheep-like, following the rest without intelligent thought, {Or do you think that most of them hear or reason? They are not except like livestock. Rather, they are more astray in [their] way.} (Quran 25:44)
Let us forge our own way, firm in faith.
Fighting Doubts
The Prophet Muhammad said:
“The people will see a time of patience in which someone adhering to his religion will be as if he were grasping a hot coal.” (At-Tirmidhi)
This is certainly one of those times. In light of this terrorism epidemic and the mounting negative public opinion towards Islam and Muslims, some of us may feel like giving up.
It’s exhausting constantly being under scrutiny, guilt-tripped, cursed at, ridiculed, and hated. Maybe this would all be easier if we just took our headscarves off, shaved our beards and changed our names to Moe.
The thing is, the solution is in the same hadith – the crux of the issue, is that we adhere to our faith – Islam. By doing so, we will become better people, who manifest the best of character and manners (thereby combating negative stereotypes, naturally) we will increase in patience and follow God’s guidance, {Repel [evil] by that which is better; and thereupon the one who between you and him is enmity [will become] as though he was a devoted friend.} (Quran 41:34)
Why should I?
{Do you think that you will enter Paradise without such (trials) as came to those who passed away before you? … Yes! Certainly, the Help of Allah is near!} (Quran 2:214)
The truth is; all of this life is intended to be a test. If it weren’t this, it would be something else. We can benefit from remembering the advice of Prophet Jacob to his sons, {Despair not of relief from Allah. Indeed, no one despairs of relief from Allah except the disbelieving people.} (Quran 12:87)
It’s a good time for us to get back to the basics, to assess our lives, and reorient our priorities. We can’t achieve any success without the aid of the Owner of the heavens and the Earth. The answers lie in the Quran and in our prayers – in our Islam.
So, let’s spend less time obsessing over the latest news and step away from the bickering and argumentation.
Let’s look into the eyes of our loved ones.
Take a moment to step outdoors and observe the beauty of God’s signs in His creation.
Let’s help one another more, give back to our communities.
And most of all, let’s spend more time with the book of Allah – the Quran. Turn off the TV. Sign out of Facebook and Twitter. Open the Quran, read it and understand it. Allah says it best. It’s all there:
{So be patient. Indeed, the promise of Allah is truth. And ask forgiveness for your sin and exalt with praise of your Lord in the evening and the morning.
Indeed, those who dispute concerning the signs of Allah without authority having come to them – there is not within their hearts except pride, [the extent of] which they cannot reach. So seek refuge in Allah. Indeed, it is He who is the Hearing, the Seeing.} (Quran 40:55-56)